Trump, Xi and Putin prepare for first trilateral summit
Donald Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin are scheduled to meet in Shenzhen on Nov. 19 for the first formal trilateral summit among the leaders of the United States, China and Russia. Their competing positions on Ukraine and nuclear arms control make agreement uncertain, while Trump has said he would not make a deal with Putin without Ukraine’s input.123
This brief is being refreshed as the reporting or market odds change.
TL;DR
- The leaders’ first formal three-way summit is a diplomatic milestone, but their conflicting positions make a major bargain on Ukraine or arms control difficult.2
- Trump’s public assurance that he will not negotiate a deal with Putin without Ukraine addresses a central concern about the summit, but does not resolve the gap between Putin’s demands and the positions Ukraine or European leaders could accept.32
- Market expectations put similar odds on Trump mentioning Ukraine or Iran during the meeting, offering a gauge of uncertainty about his remarks rather than the summit’s policy outcome.M1M2
Still to come
- The three leaders are scheduled to meet in Shenzhen on Nov. 19, with Trump also expected to hold separate meetings with Xi and Putin. Whether the discussions address the stated divides over Ukraine and nuclear arms control will test the prospects for progress beyond the summit’s symbolism.
The meeting, held on the sidelines of the APEC summit, brings together leaders with sharply different priorities. The Washington Post reports that Trump wants to focus on nuclear arms control, while Putin wants to discuss ending the war in Ukraine on terms that include a restructuring of Europe’s security order. Xi has resisted both arms-control talks and direct involvement in Ukraine negotiations, and instead wants to use the summit to bolster China’s role in global diplomacy.2
Trump sought to address concerns about Ukraine’s exclusion ahead of the meeting. In a Fox News interview from Shenzhen, he said he would not make agreements with Putin without input from Ukraine, according to Bloomberg. That stated position contrasts with the maximalist demands Putin has made in previous discussions with Trump’s envoys, which the Post says could constrain progress.32
The summit’s significance lies partly in its symbolism: Russia has promoted comparisons to the 1945 Yalta conference, while Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky has warned against a “Yalta 2.0,” the Post reports. Prediction markets on Nov. 19 put the chance Trump says “Ukraine” during the trilateral meeting at about 42%, and “Iran” at 44%. Those estimates concern whether he uses the words during the meeting, not whether the leaders reach agreements on either conflict.21M1M2
Sources
-
Apec summit live: Xi, Trump and Putin set to hold historic trilateral in China · The Guardian · Nov 19
-
Conflicting agendas and a weakened Trump mark historic three-way summit · Washington Post · Nov 19
-
Trump Says He Wouldn't Make Deals With Putin Without Ukraine · Bloomberg Business · Nov 19
AI-generated from the linked reporting and prediction-market data. Market prices reflect traders’ expectations and can change.