YOUR DAILY PERSPECTIVE

Cao’s $64 million Hormuz insurance claim remains unverified as shipping stays depressed

Acting Navy Secretary Hung Cao told senators that insurance for a commercial ship crossing the Strait of Hormuz now costs $64 million, compared with $54,000 before the war. The figure has not been independently verified, while the latest reported traffic count remained far below pre-war levels, underscoring the gap between claims of access and the risks facing shipping.1

TL;DR

  • Cao’s $64 million figure should not be treated as an established market-wide premium: the reporting says it lacks independent verification and does not specify the ship or insurance terms.1
  • The latest traffic count shows the strait is not fully closed, but passage remains substantially below pre-war levels amid restrictions and reported attacks.1
  • Market pricing adds a near-term gauge of that constraint: traders assigned much lower odds to 30 or more weekly transit calls than to a threshold of 24.M2M1

Still to come

  • Cao still needs Senate confirmation and a rare congressional waiver because he left active duty before the required seven-year separation period. Al Jazeera reported that the waiver requires a 60-vote threshold, making support for the exemption a key test for his move from acting to permanent Navy secretary.
  • Shipping restrictions and the threat of attacks remain an ongoing test of whether passage can recover beyond the low levels reported for the week ending November 11. Further traffic counts will show whether vessels are moving through the strait more regularly, against the continuing restrictions described by Al Jazeera.

Cao made the claim at his November 17 confirmation hearing, saying the current cost was for a single transit. Al Jazeera reported that maritime analyst Michelle Bockmann questioned the figure’s context, including the vessel type and the war-risk rate applied to its value. The report cited a July S&P Global estimate that insurance for a tanker carrying 270,000 metric tonnes of crude could cost about $21 million. Fox News correspondent Jennifer Griffin later posted that an unnamed source told her Cao’s figure was wrong, while noting she was seeking clarification.1X4

The broader disruption is clearer than the precise premium. UK Maritime Trade Operations recorded 308 vessel crossings in the seven days ending November 11, about 65 percent below pre-war levels, according to Al Jazeera. Some ships continue to pass, but Iran has imposed route and coordination requirements while the United States maintains a blockade of Iranian ports and says its Navy is escorting vessels. Al Jazeera also reported two tanker attacks on Monday and an Iranian claim the following day that three more tankers had struck mines.1

Prediction-market prices observed November 19 put a 33 percent probability on at least 24 qualifying transit calls during the full November 16–22 week, but only about 4 percent on at least 30. Those expectations point to a low bar for a modest amount of traffic and little confidence in a larger weekly total, consistent with the reported gap between partial passage and normal, freely flowing shipping.1M2M1

Posts on X (4)

Selected for this story

  1. Aaron Rupar @atrupar HUNG CAO: That insurance rate a year ago was $54,000. Today, it's $64 million just to get across the strait. SLOTKIN: I believe it! Because we launched a war
    View on X
  2. Jack Prandelli @jackprandelli Acting US Navy Secretary Hung Cao: “That insurance rate a year ago was $54,000. Today, it’s $64 million just to get across the strait.” He said it at his Senate confirmation hearing on Tuesday and the clip is everywhere tonight. I’d treat the $64 million with care. Brokers quoted by the Financial Times last month put Hormuz war-risk cover at 6% to 10% of a tanker’s value, up to $20 million for one supertanker voyage, against about 0.25% before the war. my view on it is here: So the real jump is closer to 40 times than 1,000 times (still enough to keep most owners out). In this war, insurance has done more to close Hormuz than mines have.
    View on X
  3. Jennifer Griffin @JenGriffinFNC ICYMI During his Senate Armed Services Committee hearing, Acting Navy Secretary Hung Cao said a single commercial ship costs $64 million dollars in risk-insurance to cross the Strait of Hormuz. Senator Elissa Slotkin (D-MI) was questioning him on the increased risk of commercial ships in the Middle East since the start of the Iran war. Cao said the insurance rate a year ago was $54,000 and today is $64 million "just to get across."  ELISSA SLOTKIN (D-MI): “Can a ship a commercial ship successfully trans transit either of the major choke points today without a formal US military escort?” ACTING SECRETARY HUNG CAO: “No, Senator, they they haven't been able to do that even before the war because, the before epic fury, because, you know, the Iranians would target them with unmanned surface vessels. I mean, we've protected 3700 merchant ships. We've been able to get one point.” ELISSA SLOTKIN (D-MI): “I don't I don't I do not quibble with how much the Navy is doing. But a year ago today did a ship, a commercial vessel carrying petroleum products, need a military escort through either the Baba Mandeb or the Strait of Hormuz, in all honesty?” ACTING SECRETARY HUNG CAO: “Well, Senator, that's why their insurance rates is $54,000. Just one transit. But it's so it's so dangerous over there, Senator. That's exactly why.” ELISSA SLOTKIN (D-MI): “A year ago today were the insurance rates. You're dodging the question. A year ago today, a commercial ship flagged for any nation could successfully transit the Baba mandeb and the Strait of Hormuz without a naval escort.” ACTING SECRETARY HUNG CAO: “Again, Senator, that that insurance rate was a year ago, 54,000 today is $64 million just to get across.” ELISSA SLOTKIN (D-MI): “I believe it because we launched a war, okay? We launched a war and we cannot have the same. We do not have the same freedom of navigation that we had a year ago.”
    View on X
  4. Jennifer Griffin @JenGriffinFNC I am told this number given by Acting Sec Hung Cao of $64 million per Hormuz passage is wrong. Seeking clarification.
    View on X

Sources

  1. US official says Hormuz insurance hits $64m: Is the strait really open? · Al Jazeera Online · Nov 18

AI-generated from the linked reporting and prediction-market data. Market prices reflect traders’ expectations and can change.

Sign up for Beta β

Get access to saves and alerts