YOUR DAILY PERSPECTIVE

Trump, Xi and Putin face a first trilateral summit with clashing agendas

Donald Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin are scheduled to hold their first trilateral meeting on Thursday in Shenzhen, bringing together the leaders of the world’s three biggest nuclear powers amid tensions over Ukraine, trade and nuclear weapons. Their sharply different priorities make the prospects for a major agreement uncertain, while the talks could affect how allies assess the leaders’ positions.12

This brief is being refreshed as the reporting or market odds change.

TL;DR

  • The summit puts arms control, Ukraine and China’s role in diplomacy on the table, but the leaders’ goals do not readily align.12
  • The market estimate that Trump will mention Ukraine reflects uncertainty about whether the topic surfaces, not the likelihood of a deal.1M1
  • The summit’s implications extend beyond the three leaders: Ukraine and European governments are wary of a deal made without their agreement, while Beijing is sensitive to great-power negotiations that exclude the country affected.12

Still to come

  • The three leaders are scheduled to meet on Thursday, alongside expected one-on-one talks. Whether they can move beyond their competing priorities will determine whether the gathering produces more than a symbolic show of access and status.
  • Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said U.S. negotiators Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner will brief allies on Thursday about Trump’s talks in China. The briefing will give the coalition of the willing an account of the discussions as Ukraine’s future is among the summit’s stated topics.

The central divide is over what the leaders want to discuss. Trump is seeking nuclear arms-control talks and has said Ukraine and Iran will also come up. Putin wants to discuss ending the war in Ukraine on terms favorable to Moscow, while Xi has resisted arms-control talks and direct involvement in negotiations over the war. The Washington Post reports that the competing agendas make a major bargain unlikely, and says Putin has made demands on Ukraine that would be difficult for Kyiv or European governments to accept.12

The meeting’s significance is also in its symbolism. The Washington Post describes it as the first time the three leaders have sat together without other leaders at the table, and says China wants to establish itself as a central player in global diplomacy. Russia, meanwhile, has invoked the 1945 Yalta conference, a comparison Ukraine’s Volodymyr Zelensky has warned against. That framing is sensitive: Beijing has sought recognition as a great power while resisting the idea of negotiating another country’s fate without its participation.2

Prediction markets put the odds at 42% that Trump will say “Ukraine” during the trilateral meeting, based on prices observed on November 19. That is a narrow measure of whether the subject is raised, not whether the leaders make progress on the war. Reuters reports that Trump intends to discuss Ukraine, but the leaders’ conflicting positions leave the substance of any exchange uncertain.1M1

Warm public gestures have preceded the summit: Putin initiated a handshake with Trump, and Xi welcomed Trump with a handshake and embrace. Those moments offer a contrast to the disagreements awaiting them, but neither establishes that policy differences will narrow.12

Posts on X (5)

Selected for this story

  1. Bloomberg @business Prime Minister Mark Carney, who will meet with Chinese President Xi Jinping on Tuesday, said Canada has other partners for auto manufacturing if the Trump administration doesn’t want an integrated North American supply chain. www.bloomberg.com
    View on X
  2. NEWSMAX @NEWSMAX CANADA TURNING TO CHINA?: Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney said that Canada could turn to Chinese automakers if trade negotiations with President Trump fail to preserve an integrated North American auto industry. Carney's comments in Cambodia on Monday came ahead of a planned meeting with Chinese President Xi Jinping this week in Shenzhen, China, where Chinese auto manufacturing is expected to be discussed. The two leaders reached an agreement in January allowing tens of thousands of Chinese electric vehicles into Canada at reduced tariffs.
    View on X
  3. Mark Carney @MarkJCarney Landed in Shenzhen to meet with President Xi and participate in the APEC Summit. Canada is strengthening our relationship with China and expanding our partnerships across Asia. We're here to build on that work — to unlock new opportunities on both sides of the Pacific.
    View on X
  4. Automotive News @Automotive_News Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney said that Canada could turn to Chinese automakers if trade negotiations with U.S. President Donald Trump fail to preserve an integrated North American auto industry. Carney’s comments in Cambodia on Nov. 16 came ahead of a planned meeting with Chinese President Xi Jinping this week in Shenzhen, China, where Chinese auto manufacturing is expected to be discussed. The two leaders reached an agreement in January allowing tens of thousands of Chinese electric vehicles into Canada at reduced tariffs. “We have the best auto workers in the world, and we want them fully deployed, full opportunity, in an integrated North American market,” Carney told reporters in Cambodia. “That market has become less integrated because of U.S. trade actions.” #Canada #China #Chinesevehicles #Chinesecars #automotive #autoindustry
    View on X
  5. John Nelson @WIgeopolitical 🇨🇦🇨🇳🇺🇸 Mark Carney is in Cambodia telling reporters Canada could turn to Chinese automakers if trade talks with Washington fail. This week he heads to Shenzhen to meet Xi Jinping, with auto manufacturing on the agenda. Asked if this was leverage against the U.S., Carney said, "It's not leverage. But action, reaction." Then he added, "Canada is going to move forward either way." It sure sounds like spending leverage. And it is a dangerous card to play. Canada already let up to 49,000 Chinese EVs in at a 6.1% tariff in January, down from 100%. Ottawa promised significant Chinese auto investment within three years. Ten months later, not one plant has been announced, and most of the quota has gone to Teslas built in China. Meanwhile, about three quarters of the jobs building cars in Canada depend on demand from the United States. Trump has already threatened a 100% tariff on Canada over a China deal and 50% on Canadian autos starting January 1. Playing Beijing off against your largest customer and closest ally is not a strategy. It is a gamble with Ontario auto workers' jobs, and China is the only one guaranteed to win it under the circumstances. Source: apnews.com
    View on X

Sources

  1. Takeaways from Day 2 of Trump's Asia tour: Putin's handshake, fried chicken and high-stakes diplomacy · Reuters · Nov 19
  2. Conflicting agendas and a weakened Trump mark historic three-way summit · Washington Post · Nov 19

AI-generated from the linked reporting and prediction-market data. Market prices reflect traders’ expectations and can change.

Sign up for Beta β

Get access to saves and alerts